But there are a number of risks that need to be clearly understood and managed. Some cells should be immediately discarded. Any cell with a voltage below 2.5 volts is unsafe to recharge. Some say 2.75 volts and perhaps even a higher rejection voltage should be chosen. but we are getting ahead of ourselves.
After doing this for a couple of years and getting some experience, I have developed some preferences in brands of cells. Panasonic and Sony seem to be the best. Samsung and LG can be good also. I have seen varied results from the red Sanyo cells. Some are fine, but I have had quite a few get really hot when being charged, much more so than other brands.
Unbranded cells from China have been quite variable. Some are terrible with a short life after which they refuse to take a charge. I have seen some sit forever at 3.6 volts and never charge. Some are fine. The good ones are marked "ASO" -- whoever "ASO" is seems to be making a good product.
Disassembling a laptop battery is a somewhat hazardous process. You probably have no idea what the state of charge of the pack is, and it is very likely to be holding a significant charge. This means if you short out any cells, or puncture a battery, very bad things can happen.
Also, any cells harvested from a laptop (or any other) battery will be unprotected cells. You can read a lot about this elsewhere (and you should), but the main issue here is that you must take care to avoid excessively discharging the cell. The circuitry in a laptop battery takes care of this, but once you take a cell out of this managed environment, you are responsible. If you discharge a cell below a certain point (lets say 3.5 volts) it becomes dangerous and unstable.
Overcharging is equally bad, if not more so, but if you are using a reputable charger, this is not an issue. If you are going to use unprotected cells, you absolutely should invest in a quality charger like the XTAR I use.
Here is how one guy does it:
Another fellow says he uses the following guidelines. I used them for a while, but have started recovering a lot of batteries that measure less than 2.5 volts. It is certainly safe to follow his first guideline, but you will miss some treasures.
I am tempted to say that any unbranded cells may as well just be discarded. I have now learned to (given a choice) only harvest batteries from brand name packs like Dell, HP, Compaq and such -- avoid generic replacement packs, both for harvesting cells, and for replacing the battery in your laptop!
Suburban Miners, 3820 E. Blacklidge, 520-406-7446
SIMS Recycling solutions, 820 S. Euclid, 520-622-7600
Tom's electronics pages / tom@mmto.org